The first time a Boston crowd heard I Had A Dream That You Were Mine, Hamilton Leithauser performed it sans Rostam at the Sinclair—a show that opened with then burgeoning singer songwriter Lucy Dacus (of pre-boygenius fame). Leithauser has performed tracks off the record at subsequent solo Boston shows, often peppering in stories behind the songs. But with Rostam onstage, fans heard more of the lore: The incident inspiring “The Bride’s Dad” may have been familiar to most in the crowd, but Rostam revealed that Leithauser had initially dismissed the instrumentals, saying it sounded too much like a “Christmas song.” “This’ll get you into the holiday spirit!” they exclaimed as the twinkling piano began.
Throughout the night, the two rotated in and out to give each other a chance to play their solo material, treating the crowd to hits like “Bike Dream” and “Alexandra” before coming back together to remind us that the decade-long wait to hear them perform their record together was well worth it.




















